[Russia] - 'We Are Being Held Without Protection': North Caucasus Women Decry Dire Conditions in Kurdish-Run Syrian Camps

INSUBCONTINENT EXCLUSIVE:
There are 2,000 Dagestani females without children in the Al-Hawl and Roj camps, which are under Kurdish control in Syria, stated L., a
Dagestani female recently rescued from Al-Hawl, a sprawling detention facility in northeastern Syria.Many more families with children are
likewise held there
I dont know the specific number, however our living conditions are definitely excruciating, she said, speaking on condition of privacy for
safety reasons.Located near the Iraqi border, Al-Hawl was initially established to house Iraqi refugees running away the Gulf War and, later
on, the U.S.-led intrusion of Iraq
Today, it holds countless women and children, a lot of them loved ones of Islamic State fighters, under the control of Kurdish-led
forces.Women and children are subjected to abuse and whippings by the Kurdish authorities, L
said
We are being held with no legal defense, in dreadful conditions
Some of us dont simply reside in tents, however in prison toilets basically latrines converted into cells
Even healthy individuals establish heart disease and agreement tuberculosis in those cells.L
is among numerous women identified as affiliated with the Islamic State (ISIS), the terrorist company that took swathes of area in Syria and
Iraq in 2014 and declared a caliphate
While IS still exists in some form, the self-proclaimed state collapsed in late 2019 after the battle of Baghuz Fawqani.In the consequences,
partners, sisters and children of ISIS fighters, a lot of whom are foreign nationals, were sent to Kurdish-controlled camps in northeastern
Syria.There are no exact figures on how many females and kids from Russia and its annexed areas are being held in these camps, but lots of
appear to hail from the North Caucasus
Households detained in these camps explain traumatic living conditions and state they feel they have been abandoned by the global
community.Some kids have actually invested their entire lives in detention, either being born in the camps or brought in as babies
throughout the final battles with ISIS
Others were preschoolers at the time and hardly remember the group.For six years, children aged 12 and older have actually been drawn from
Al-Hawl and separated from their moms, basically locked in special jails for teens, L
stated
The conditions they live in are dreadful
You can envision the trauma theyve endured, being separated from their mothers and siblings
No matter a moms past, she is still a mom
And children must not be penalized for their moms and dads mistakes.A female walks with a saline infusion on her hand at the Al-Amal
Camp.Zaid AL-Obeidi/ AFPAccording to L., moms are often left in the dark about their boys whereabouts
A handful of kids have actually been returned to families, she explained these instances as manipulative gestures rather than systemic
change.In Roj, this specific practice does not exist, but even there, Kurdish authorities are vicious toward children, including young
children, abusing them physically and mentally
When the media are nearby, they pretend to be kind
When the electronic cameras are gone, they reveal their real faces, she said.On social media platforms such as Telegram and Facebook, North
Caucasus women consistently organize fundraisers for warm clothes and blankets for their imprisoned kids, or to pay kickbacks to Kurdish
guards in hopes of protecting their release.The Chechens have actually virtually ransomed all their fellow residents
There are far fewer Chechen households left in the camps, said Ansar Dishni, an agent of NIYSO, a Chechen self-reliance organization.He said
his group frequently receives demands for aid raising the cash required to totally free someone.There are many groups that pay allurements
to get women and children out of the camps if youre able to pay, added Ali Charinskiy, a representative of the Independent Dagestan in
Ukraine initiative
It costs around $15,000 to get someone out
I know, because I personally assisted to ransom and free one family from the camp.Charinskiy likewise blamed Russian authorities for
funneling disaffected youth toward Syria in the early years of the war.Before 2014, the authorities in the North Caucasus were pressing
young Muslims who might withstand, he explained
The FSB allowed individuals to leave for Syria, doing nothing to prevent households from joining the anti-Assad resistance or even terrorist
groups
Their objective was to eliminate Muslim youth who might engage in Islamic uniformity or the Dagestani freedom movement
And after that Russia pertained to Syria to combat for Assad, and bombed them.Dishni echoed that view, associating youth radicalization to
decades of Russian repression.The main factor was stringent control and persecution by Russian authorities
Thats what drove numerous young families to leave, he said.While Russia had a function in producing the conditions that led to the camps, it
has actually done little in the way of resolving the crisis.Inside Russia, the plight of ISIS-affiliated women and kids is taboo, and even
discussing it can lead to criminal charges.In July 2024, Russian theater director Zhenya Berkovich and playwright Svetlana Petriychuk were
sentenced to 6 years in prison for justifying terrorism over their play Finist, the Brave Falcon, which tells the story of Russian women
enticed into joining ISIS fighters in Syria
The play plainly condemns ISIS, its subject matter showed too politically charged.In contrast, British author Nussaibah Younis 2025
satirical unique Fundamentally, about a London scholastic trying to rescue a former ISIS bride from a Syrian camp, became a bestseller and
was shortlisted for the Womens Prize for Fiction.And in 2019, Azadeh Moavenis Guest House for Young Widows, a nonfiction account of 13 women
linked to ISIS, was named one of the years best books by The New York Times, The Toronto Star and The Guardian.Experts agree that early
intervention is key for deradicalization
The earlier kids are eliminated from such camps, the much better their prospects
Return efforts stay inconsistent.Though some women and children have been returned to the North Caucasus, the process is sluggish and
complicated.We understand of just a few isolated cases where women who voluntarily returned from the camps were subjected to criminal
prosecution, said Dishni of NIYSO.Generally, in Chechnya and other parts of the area, families of previous ISIS members face little
methodical prosecution, he stated
While returnees are evaluated, these procedures hardly ever intensify into persecution.However, he cautioned that in Russia, where the
repressive machine operates outside the law, nobody is genuinely safe
Even if not officially charged, females went back to Chechnya may deal with intimidation and harassment, he said.Charinskiy, from
Independent Dagestan in Ukraine, described cases in which Dagestani women deported back to Dagestan were separated from their kids and
jailed.Thats why numerous ladies are afraid to return, he said.Whether to return or remain is a deeply personal choice, stated L., the
Dagestani woman
Everybody has their own plans and preferences
But right now, Syria seems like the safer option.Still, numerous women state they wish to go home.Theres no one-size-fits-all response, said
Dishni
Each case is unique
You need to think about broader aspects local dynamics, global policies and how returnees are treated.He added that sometimes, returning
teens to their prolonged families in the North Caucasus may use the most gentle and stable path forward.The household structure there is
based upon shared assistance
If these kids are surrounded by their liked ones, they may discover stability, care and a path to reintegration, he said.The political
landscape in Syria is likewise shifting
Since the fall of Bashar al-Assads routine, the brand-new Salvation Government led by President Ahmed al-Sharaa has actually discussed
releasing detainees from Kurdish camps and has actually apparently opened settlements with Kurdish forces though no concrete development has
been made.L
said that conditions have actually worsened under the Kurdish authorities, who are now relinquishing responsibility.With the arrival of
brand-new authorities, we expect the development of more transparent and legal mechanisms for saving the ladies and children caught in these
camps, Dishni said
We expect that proficient bodies within the new Syrian government will establish channels for their release and guarantee their safety.Im
sure the new federal government is preoccupied with other problems today, so the women and kids from Roj and Al-Hawl are not their concern
And the Kurds see them as bargaining chips, Charinskiy stated
Its an embarassment, but I hope it will alter.